Samantar ruling portends legal danger to alleged foreign torturers

[TamilNet, Wednesday, 02 June 2010, 11:20 GMT]
In an unanimous ruling at the United States Supreme Court, the judges said that a federal law that protects foreign government officials from law suits filed in the U.S. does not cover individuals such as Mohamed Ali Samantar, who was a prime minister in the 1980s in the now ousted government of Siad Biarre. A group of Somalis who allege torture and killings by Samantar's government may pursue legal action against Samantar now living in Fairfax, Virginia, the court ruled.

Smantar, former Somali minister
Smantar, former Somali minister
"Faced with a choice between accountability and immunity, the Supreme Court squarely came down in favor of accountability," said Pamela Merchant, executive director of the Center for Justice and Accountability in San Francisco, according to Washington Post.

"Congress passed the Torture Victims Protection Act (TVPA) because they did not want torturers who have committed serious human rights crimes to seek safe haven in the United States. The Supreme Court's decision means that the U.S. will not serve as a safe haven," Ms Merchant said.

The legal organization that represented those who sued Samantar said the decision gives teeth to the remedy Congress supplied to let victims recover damages from those who have moved to the United States after committing human rights violations in their home countries.

Lawyers for Samantar and some members of the diplomatic corps had argued to the court that a decision in favor of Bashe Yousef and four other Samantar accusers could have powerful foreign policy implications, and could open U.S. officials to lawsuits in foreign courts.

The court warned that its decision was narrow and that Samantar might have other legal claims of immunity when a district court reconsiders the suit. "Whether petitioner [Samantar] may be entitled to immunity under common law, and whether he may have other valid defenses to the grave charges against him, are matters to be addressed" by lower courts, Stevens wrote, according to Washington Post.

A spokesperson for the US-based pressure group, Tamils Against Genocide (TAG), said, "this ruling is significant for Tamils. Sri Lanka officials who are alleged to have committed war crimes, can no longer claim sovereign immunity in US. Statute of limitations on egragious crimes can be several decades."


Chronology:


External Links:
OYEZ: Samantar v. Yousuf
ScotusWiki: Samantar v. Yousuf
DD: Amici Curiae Brief for Samantar v. Yousuf

 

Latest 15 Reports
26.03.20 23:38   Photo
Monk praises Gota for releasing SLA soldier from death row, celebrates genocidaire soldier as “hero”
25.03.20 23:06   Photo
Island-wide Corona infection estimated at 550 with spread risk to 19,000 persons
24.03.20 16:26   Photo
US escalates tensions in South China Sea amidst Corona pandemic, Chinese media blame
23.03.20 22:52   Photo
UNHRC urged to adopt multitrack investigations, including SL State responsibility for genocide
22.03.20 22:05  
Colombo set to receive more concessional loans from China
21.03.20 22:51   Photo
India, France carry out joint surveillance mission from Reunion Island
20.03.20 19:34  
Trump Administration politicises MCC assistance: US policy analyst
19.03.20 21:34   Photo
Bay of Bengal study notes development disparity between North-East and South
18.03.20 22:57  
China Development Bank extends syndicated loan to Colombo by $500 million
17.03.20 22:51  
Gotabaya appoints Silva as head of SL operation centre to prevent corona outbreak
16.03.20 22:26  
UN Rights Chief must act to refer “Sri Lanka” crimes to ICC
15.03.20 18:46   Photo
Phil Miller’s work reveals British role in dividing Tamils and Muslims in East: Dr Malathy
14.03.20 23:47   Photo
Moragoda’s “think tank” justifies Sinhala apprehension to MCC, proposes renegotiations
13.03.20 23:22   Photo
Australia upgrades air defence boosting strategic military ties with US to deter China in Indo-Pacific
12.03.20 23:47   Photo
US, UK conduct 24-day long Bay of Bengal military ‘interoperability’ training with Bangladesh
 
Find this article at:
http://www.tamilnet.com/art.html?catid=13&artid=31884