US attaché clarification, a linguistic legerdemain, accuses Boyle

[TamilNet, Monday, 06 June 2011, 00:03 GMT]
Response from the US State Department on the comments made this week by US defence attaché Lt. Col. Lawrence Smith in Colombo at the controversial 3-day seminar organised by the Sri Lankan military to expound on its defeat of the LTTE earlier this week that the remarks "reflected his personal opinions," and that "[t]hey [the comments] do not reflect the policy of the United States Government,” was "all linguistic legerdemain by the United States Government," accused Professor Francis Boyle, an expert in International Law and a professor at the University of Illinois School of Law.

Prof Francis A Boyle
Prof Francis A Boyle
US defence attaché Lt. Col. Lawrence Smith (Courtesy: Sunday Times)
US defence attaché Lt. Col. Lawrence Smith
"This Defense Attaché is high-level Diplomatic Agent for the United States government protected by diplomatic privileges and immunities under international law and relevant treaties. He acts only pursuant to Instructions by his Government. Thus the United States government did accept the invitation by the GOSL to attend and participate in this Conference and to make this Statement," asserts Prof. Boyle.

"His [attaché's] Statement was made acting pursuant to Instructions by the United States government and represents the Official Position of the United States Government. In this case, he could have been acting pursuant to Instructions by the Pentagon and not by the State Department, which proves who really is conducting the foreign policy of the United States Government," Boyle explained, alerting the Tamil expatriate activists of the likely policy underpinning of US diplomatic behavior viś-a-viś Sri Lanka.

"As for the substance of his Statement, I see no point here in trying to establish precisely what happened during the denouement of the GOSL’s genocidal massacre of about 50,000 Tamils in Vanni two years ago.

"That is why we need the U.N. Secretary General Ban Ki-Moon to establish an International War Crimes Investigation Commission to look into it, which he has admitted he has the power to do unilaterally. Whatever these circumstances of surrender by LTTE leaders might have been, so long as they were waiving a White Flag or its functional Equivalent—and all reports indicate they were—they were not legitimate targets of attack. Killing someone waiving a White Flag or its Equivalent during armed combat is a serious war crime," Boyle said.

"Why did this US Defense Attaché, probably acting pursuant to Instructions by the Pentagon, want to muddy the waters and confuse the legal situation to the benefit of the GOSL?" Boyle further questioned the motivation behind the US Defense Attaché's conduct.


Chronology:


Related Articles:
06.06.11   Paradigm hub is Sri Lanka: Jaffna academic responds to Choms..


External Links:
USGov: Sri Lanka Defense Symposium

 

Latest 15 Reports
26.03.20 23:38   Photo
Monk praises Gota for releasing SLA soldier from death row, celebrates genocidaire soldier as “hero”
25.03.20 23:06   Photo
Island-wide Corona infection estimated at 550 with spread risk to 19,000 persons
24.03.20 16:26   Photo
US escalates tensions in South China Sea amidst Corona pandemic, Chinese media blame
23.03.20 22:52   Photo
UNHRC urged to adopt multitrack investigations, including SL State responsibility for genocide
22.03.20 22:05  
Colombo set to receive more concessional loans from China
21.03.20 22:51   Photo
India, France carry out joint surveillance mission from Reunion Island
20.03.20 19:34  
Trump Administration politicises MCC assistance: US policy analyst
19.03.20 21:34   Photo
Bay of Bengal study notes development disparity between North-East and South
18.03.20 22:57  
China Development Bank extends syndicated loan to Colombo by $500 million
17.03.20 22:51  
Gotabaya appoints Silva as head of SL operation centre to prevent corona outbreak
16.03.20 22:26  
UN Rights Chief must act to refer “Sri Lanka” crimes to ICC
15.03.20 18:46   Photo
Phil Miller’s work reveals British role in dividing Tamils and Muslims in East: Dr Malathy
14.03.20 23:47   Photo
Moragoda’s “think tank” justifies Sinhala apprehension to MCC, proposes renegotiations
13.03.20 23:22   Photo
Australia upgrades air defence boosting strategic military ties with US to deter China in Indo-Pacific
12.03.20 23:47   Photo
US, UK conduct 24-day long Bay of Bengal military ‘interoperability’ training with Bangladesh
 
Find this article at:
http://www.tamilnet.com/art.html?catid=13&artid=34034