Sarath case descends into farce

[TamilNet, Wednesday, 01 December 1999, 18:34 GMT]
A judge must not hear a case against him is a sacred maxim. It holds equally true that a judge must not nominate judges to hear the case against him, President's Counsel Ranjith Abeysuriya told the Supreme Court today.

He was addressing the Supreme Court in support of the three petitions challenging the appointment of Sarath N. Silva as Chief Justice.

sarath_silva_2-p.gifMr. Abeysuriya continued that though the case in issue is against the Chief Justice, under the constitution it is the Chief Justice who is empowered with the authority to nominate judges.

In such a context, the Chief Justice should act with caution. The concept enshrined by the 'Justice should not only be done, but also appear to be done is a concept' should be safely guarded.

The selection process of judges has led to speculation whether there the procedure is fully impartial. Such speculation is detrimental to the institution of the judiciary.

The Chief Justice should have selected the judges on the basis of seniority, but happened to look for the judges who are appointed.

Thus ensued the following dialogue:

Court:- Why should you bother to know who the judges are?

Counsel:- To be successful, a lawyer ought to know the judge, before whom he was going to appear.

Court:- Why?

Counsel Judges are also human beings. They have their own slants Lawyers have to address the judge accordingly to persuade them.

Court:- It is unfair to make such comments. Judges have receptive mind and are prone to persuasion.

Mr. Abeysruiya added that the number of judges appointed to hear was another matter of complaint. In view of the seriousness of the issue, there ought to have been the maximum number of judges possible. But in this case the number was seven.

He went on that the judges had not been selected on the basis of seniority. He said that this case has aroused interest all over the world, so much so that the international Bar Association has sent a representative as an observer, he concluded.

The Bench comprised Justices S.B.Wadugodapitiya (Chairman), Priyantha Perera, S.B.G.Wijetunge, Shiranie Bandaranayaka, D.P.S.Gunasekera, S.H.Weerasekera, and Ameer Ismail.

Ravaya Editor Victor Ivan, Sunday Times Deputy Editor Rajpal Abeynaike and A.Jayasekera are the petitioners in the case.

A further hearing has been postponed until February 7, 2000.

 

Latest 15 Reports
27.11.20 16:44   Photo
Occupied Tamil Eelam marks Heroes' Day indoors, SL military detains seminary principal
16.11.20 18:45  
China launches world’s biggest regional trade agreement without Indian participation
31.10.20 10:58  
Tamils risk Kashmir-like status revocation if Gota continues Trinco military cooperation with US
06.10.20 11:40  
Poet Pulamaipithan who championed Tamil Eelam solidarity in Tamil Nadu turns 85
28.09.20 23:19   Photo
Muslims join Tamils opposing Colombo's suppression of Thileepan Remembrance in North
27.09.20 12:05   Photo
Tamils unify to mark Thileepan Remembrance, brave Colombo's suppression of memorialisation
26.09.20 09:10   Photo
Commemorating sacrifices of Tamil struggle is an inalienable right, not a subject for ‘SL permission’
25.09.20 22:08   Photo
South Asia mourns SPB's demise
15.09.20 06:37   Photo
UN Rights Chief joins her predecessors in watering down collective rights of genocide affected people
04.09.20 22:13   Photo
Diaspora youth group re-aligns Tamil narrative on enforced disappearances
03.09.20 15:41   Photo
Jude Lal Fernando’s Sputnik interview exposes unfolding British duplicity on KMS ‘investigations’
02.09.20 22:03   Photo
Gotabaya's ‘Task Force’ monk threatens Tamils to stay away from their paddy fields in Thiriyaay
01.09.20 23:36  
Colombo extends genocidal land grab targeting farmlands of Tamils along NE border: Ravikaran
31.08.20 16:36   Photo
Families of war-disappeared send strong message braving SL restrictions on International Day
08.08.20 01:05   Photo
Sumanthiran alleged of exerting Colombo’s influence to tamper with preferential vote counts
 
Find this article at:
http://www.tamilnet.com/art.html?catid=13&artid=4272